There's Something for Everyone at MaMa's Pizzeria

Come try our pizzeria formerly known as Tony's Pizza with the same owners and chef in Bayville, NJ today

If you're looking for the most popular pizzeria in Bayville, NJ, you've come to the right place. MaMa's Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant you don't want to miss out on. Our Italian food staples have local residents buzzing. As a family-owned and operated business, we treat all our customers like family. Our chefs know how to bring the heat to classic Italian dishes and more. If you're ready to place an order, you can do so through Slice!

Dining room rentals and catering made just for you

When you come to MaMa's Pizzeria, you can count on mouthwatering food that will leave you wanting more. Along with our standard menu, we also offer Italian food catering and dining room rentals. These options are great for larger families who want extra space to enjoy their meal or those who want to take their MaMa's Pizzeria meal to go. Our catered dishes allow you to spread the love of our food to your friends and family easily.

If you have questions about our catering or dining room rental services, reach out to us for more information.

All your favorite Italian dishes in one place

If you're looking for a great place to host a family dinner, MaMa's Pizzeria is it. BYOB to enjoy some Italian staples you are sure to love. Some of our most popular dishes include:

  • Pizza
  • Pasta
  • Calzones
  • Stromboli
  • Cold and hot subs
If you're not sure what to get at our pizzeria, take advantage of our weekly specials to try something new.

Come down to MaMa's Pizzeria today to see why locals are raving about our pizza restaurant.